Tree care

Stump grinding or full stump removal: which do you need?

Almost always grinding. Full removal is for when a foundation, pool or driveway is going over the spot. How to tell which one your stump needs.

DBy David’s Tree Service3 min read

Once a tree comes down, the stump is still in your way. There are two ways to deal with it, and the right one depends on what’s going in that spot afterward.

Quick answerAlmost always grinding. It takes the stump four to six inches below grade, which is enough for topsoil and grass, and leaves your lawn largely intact. Full removal digs out the whole root mass, and it’s only worth it when a foundation, a pool or a driveway is going over that spot.

Grinding versus full removal

GrindingFull removal
DepthSeveral inches below gradeThe whole stump and root mass
RootsFlare roots ground outDug out
Speed and costFaster and cheaperA much bigger job
Your lawnLargely intactTorn up over a much bigger area
When it’s the answerLawn, beds, most yardsA foundation, a pool or a driveway over the spot

Why take the stump out at all

  • You can’t mow over it. A stump at ankle height is something you steer around for the next twenty years.
  • It’s a trip hazard, especially once the grass grows over it and you forget exactly where it is.
  • It sprouts. Plenty of species send up suckers from the stump and roots for years. Black locust is a determined offender.
  • It attracts insects and decay. A rotting stump is a food source sitting next to your house.
  • You want to build there. You can’t put a new tree, a shed or a fence post through an old root plate.

Planting a new tree in the same spot

Say so up front. A new root ball won’t establish in a bed of old chips and roots, so we grind deeper and wider and clear the debris out, so there’s room for real soil.

Tell us what’s going in there afterward and we’ll tell you which one you need.

Not sure which yours needs?Send a photo with something for scale, or call and we’ll come look. Free estimate.

Get a free estimate

What happens to the hole

We can rake the chips back in and level it, which is what most people want. Or we haul the chips away and you fill it with topsoil. Either way it settles over the first few months, so expect to top it up once.

The cheapest time to do it

If we’re already on site taking a tree down, grinding the stump at the same time is the cheapest it will ever be. Standard removal leaves the stump cut low to the ground, so ask for both when you get the quote. More on our stump grinding page.

Frequently asked questions

Will the roots keep growing?

No. Once the stump is ground out and separated from the trunk, the remaining roots die off and rot down over several years. Grinding also stops the suckering.

Standard is four to six inches below grade, which is enough to put topsoil and grass over it. Deeper and wider if you’re replanting.

Yes. Virginia requires utilities to be located before digging, and grinding counts. We handle the notification. Tell us about anything private, like septic lines, irrigation, invisible fence or drainage.

Yes. Bedford, Forest and the rest of Bedford County, plus Lynchburg and Campbell and Pittsylvania counties.

D

About David’s Tree Service

David Snead started the business in Lynch Station in 1993 and still runs the crew. He quotes the job and he works on it. Licensed and insured, covering Campbell, Bedford and Pittsylvania counties and Lynchburg. More about us

Not sure about a tree?

David comes out, looks at it and gives you a price. No charge and no obligation.

or call 540-297-3454

Why David’s
  • ✓4.8★ from 127 Google reviews
  • ✓Licensed and insured
  • ✓Family run since 1993
  • ✓Free estimates, no obligation
  • ✓24/7 emergency line
Call us

540-297-3454Main office

540-871-833824/7 emergencies

434-525-6777Forest / Lynchburg

7315 Bishop Creek Rd
Lynch Station, VA 24571

Google reviews

What our customers say

★★★★★ 4.8★ from 127 Google reviews

Read all reviews →

Posted on Google Google
Jeffrey schultz profile picture
Jeffrey schultz
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Great service, we had a huge oak come down and David was able to clean up the tree and carry away the pieces and remove the stump. Cleaned up the area well and left no sign that there was ever a tree there. He had all the equipment needed and the experience to get the job done efficiently. We’re b Very pleased with the entire effort.
Posted on Google Google
C Wolfer profile picture
C Wolfer
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
David and his team did a great job taking down a very large hickory tree and other dead/dying trees at our wooded farm. They cleaned up afterwards. Excellent job.
Posted on Google Google
Paul Peltier profile picture
Paul Peltier
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I would very much recommend his services.
Posted on Google Google
J Lem profile picture
J Lem
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I needed a tree service company to cut 3 large oak trees that were leaning toward my house. I searched online and saw a list of tree services. One stood out with 6 positive reviews -- David's Tree Services. I called and David came out and gave me an estimate. He backed it up with a written proposal. I accepted and he was at work the next day. He did an outstanding job of cutting down the 3 large oak trees, grinding their stumps plus grinding 2 other old stumps, cutting the branches off of a neighbors tree that hung over my yard, took off the branches of a large neighbor's tree that leaned toward my house, cut off an underground root of a tree that was pushing my concrete drive up, and trimmed away branches from my overhead power line that could cause trouble in the future. He had all of the equipment including stump grinding. When he finished, not a leaf was left in the yard. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND DAVID'S TREE SERVICES.
Posted on Google Google
steven branning profile picture
steven branning
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I cannot say enough good things about David's tree service. He has basically saved my house. We had a 58-ft tree 3 ft from the house that was beginning to die. He was able to get that tree cleared. We had a tree that was beginning to reach a neighbor's house, he was able to clear that tree also. All in all we had five trees removed and all the ivy that was climbing my house that I'm allergic to. He was able to clear it to get us ready for our roof that's getting replaced. With all this work that was performed, the price was extremely reasonable and David's is such a nice gentleman. His crew is exceptional. Every one of the gentlemen I met were very friendly and nice
Posted on Google Google
Kathy Dodson profile picture
Kathy Dodson
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Very professional. Great crew. Cleared and cleaned up all debris. Very impressed with their work.
Posted on Google Google
Jacob Shelley profile picture
Jacob Shelley
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Hard to get ahold of and confirm a time/if they can do the service. First time dealing with them was great but sadly did not have a good experience with a tree second time around.
Posted on Google Google
Dgkeller Keller profile picture
Dgkeller Keller
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We’ve had the pleasure of working with David’s Tree Services twice now. David and his team took down a few very large oak trees and a few tree of heaven in 2024. The work was top notch and price was more than fair. We asked for his help again recently to take out an ugly overgrown row of cedars that shaded the driveway in winter and was full of weeds. David came out within a day, made quick work of the removal and left the area so clean, its like the cedars were never there! The work was finished in less than a day! I consider David’s Tree Services the ONLY Tree Service to call in the Bedford County area.
Posted on Google Google
Tim Vasser profile picture
Tim Vasser
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Have used them in the past, however the last time we called them they never came, we called again and was told they were coming, still nobody showed up.
Posted on Google Google
Daryl Woods profile picture
Daryl Woods
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
David and his crew just cut down a “monster” tree at our property in Thaxton. The tree was enormous-probably 200 years old. David really knew what he was doing and he tackled the project professionally, quickly and safely. Afterwards He spent a lot of leveling the ground and cleaning up the roots. David was fair-priced for the job. I would definitely use him again. I highly recommend him.
Ready to get started?

Call and we’ll
come look.

Every job starts with a free estimate, and the same crew that quotes it does the work.

540-297-3454
Tree down right now? Call our 24/7 emergency line, 540-871-8338.

Get a free estimate

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
The fastest way to get you a price.
What do you need?(Required)
How big, how close to the house, anything we should know. A rough idea is fine.
A photo helps a lot. It often saves a trip and gets you a price faster.
Accepted file types: jpg, jpeg, png, heic, Max. file size: 10 MB.
Is this an emergency?
If it is urgent, call our 24/7 emergency line, 540-871-8338, rather than waiting on this form.